• Home
  • The Team
  • Contact TUS
  • Topics
    • Amazing
    • Funny
    • Gadgets
    • Gaming
    • Geek
    • Film
    • Product Review
    • Seriously?
    • Technology

John Williams vs Hans Zimmer


Posted by The Shogun on 29 Aug 2010 / 6 Comments
Tweet



John_Williams

Upon leaving the cinema after watching Inception this summer, I came with a profound new love for movie soundtracks. You simply cannot have an amazing film without an amazing soundtrack. And in my mind, there are no two better composers in the business than the legendary John Williams and of course Hans Zimmer. But my question is, who do you prefer?

 

Of course at the end of the day, it’s all just a matter of opinion. But I thought it was a rather interesting debate. John Williams on one hand has under his belt, some of the greatest films of all times with Jurassic Park and E.T. for example which I’m sure if you’re in my generation will forever be adorned as the true classic films of our era. Then there’s Hans Zimmer whose catalogue of films is also impressive with arguably one of my favourite films of all time in Gladiator. There’s a clear contrast in styles here but in the end, it really does come down to what you’d prefer. Either the instantly recognisable tunes from John Williams, or the atmospheric rollercoaster that comes from Hans Zimmer.

 

To help you decide, I’ve listed down 8 of my favourite songs from both directors.

 

Let me know what you think in the comments section, Twitter or on my Facebook page. All the links as usual can be found in the sidebar.

Written by The Shogun

Soul Editor, Writer and Creator of TheUrbanShogun.com

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/HOWQTHPKYXR7AC5Z5BHU6C2SDM matt

    Okay so this is just a comparison of the top 5-10 movies each has done

    ZImmerDays of Thunder-(NASCAR and Tom Cruise… Winning)
    Backdraft (Kurt Russle and Firefighters..Boom Baby)A League of Their Own (All Star Cast, except Rosie haha GREAT Score)Cool Runnings (Most epic ending scene EVER, music KILLS ya)Lion King (Winning!!)
    Crimson Tide (Go Bama’, ROLL TIDE!!) The Rock (Okay fine,  Nick Cage but 007 himself and a AWESOME Score) Prince of Egypt (Another All Star Cast and brilliant orchestra work)Gladiator (EPIC)
    and Sherlock Holmes (2009 version with RDJ) John Williams
    Harry Potter (Good)
    Jurasic Park (Cool)
    Star WARS (Okay Fine you win)Indiana Jone (EPIC)Hook and JAWSJohn Williams Takes it, but look at Zimmer, GREAT STUFF!

  • DJdaSoundguy

    Though they really are quite different from one another, Zimmer using synths to create very powerful tracks and using epic sounding chord progressions, and Williams who uses the orchestra (and rarely an electric guitar, or at least that’s what it sounds like in one specific track from star wars 2: attack of the clones). I definitely choose John Williams over Zimmer. I think Zimmer has a more epic feel in a lot of his pieces, but it still cannot compete with the super genius that Williams inserts in his pieces.

  • Terpboi79

    Love them both but I’d say John Williams.  As a music major, I’d have to say a 100 years from now, William’s music could become the repertoire of a philharmonic/symphony orchestra of any major city, while Zimmer’s music will probably fade away, after all Pirates of the Carib, is a clear variation from the Barbarian Horde piece from Gladiator.

    • DJdaSoundguy

      The first pirates of the caribbean soundtrack was composed by Klaus Badelt.

  • Omfgurgay

    Man, thats really hard, but I’ve gotta say Hanz Zimmer by a bit.

    • http://www.theurbanshogun.com Shogun168

      It’s tough ain’t it!

  • Search

  • Similar posts you might like...

    • Film
      • Review - Avengers Assemble
      • The Urban Shogun Writers' Film of 2011
      • What Was Your Favourite Film Of The Year?
      • Emperor Palpatine Was Originally Played by ... a Woman
      • The Avengers Trailer
    • Music
      • Star Wars Duel ... Cello Style
      • Nerdcore: The Firefly Rap Album
      • Star Wars' Imperial March on ... two floppy drives
      • Rebecca Black's "Friday" taken off YouTube after most Dislikes ever
      • Able Planet's Sound Clarity ANC Headphones Review
  • Recent Posts

    • Google I/O Highlights
      May 18, 2013
    • Roll in, the Samsung Galaxy Tab 3
      May 1, 2013
    • Facebook Home hits the half million mark
      April 23, 2013


  • Recent Comments

    • Mark Glover on Iron Man’s House is up for Sale
    • Why Should My Business Blog? on The QWERTY arrangement of the Keyboard was created to SLOW down typing
    • Russty Fiedler on The Red Juice in Raw Red Meat Isn’t Actually Blood
    • Grüner Berg in China gibt weiter Rätsel auf on Mountain in China is Painted Green
    • Kernos on Lex Luthor’s mansion and the school in X-Men are one and the same!
  • Meta

    • Log in
    • Entries RSS
    • Comments RSS
  • Subscribe

    • Subscribe to the Feed
  • Search


Copyright © 2012. | The Urban Shogun